Surprised Woman Pays With A 1981 Susan B. Anthony Dollar — It Was Worth $940,000

The Coin That Wasn’t Just Change

In an unexpected twist that has excited the coin collecting community, a woman unknowingly used a rare 1981 Susan B. Anthony dollar—now estimated to be worth around $940,000—to pay for a simple cup of coffee. What started as a routine payment quickly turned into a historic moment for numismatics.

This intriguing tale began at a small café in Pennsylvania. A woman, believed to be in her 60s, handed a Susan B. Anthony dollar to the cashier. The barista, noticing the coin’s unusual shine and distinctive design, decided to set it aside rather than placing it into the register. That evening, the barista posted a photo of the coin in an online coin collecting group, curious about its possible significance.

What followed was astonishing. A respected numismatist responded promptly, warning the barista not to trade or spend the coin. Upon further analysis, it was confirmed to be a rare 1981-S Susan B. Anthony dollar with a Type 2 proof finish — a version virtually never seen in everyday circulation.

Why It’s So Valuable

The 1981-S Susan B. Anthony dollar wasn’t meant for general use. It came from a limited collector-only production. The true rarity lies in its “Type 2” proof finish — this version features a sharper, more distinct mint mark compared to the more common “Type 1.”

Very few of these coins were made, and even fewer left the U.S. Mint’s sets. Because of this, their presence in public circulation is nearly unheard of. When found in pristine condition, as in this case, these coins can sell at auction for enormous amounts. Coins graded at “PR70” — the highest proof rating possible — have sold for well over $900,000.

The condition of the discovered coin appeared nearly flawless, attracting significant attention from collectors and auction firms across the country.

How Did It End Up in Her Wallet?

Experts speculate that the woman may have come into possession of the coin unknowingly, possibly through an inheritance or as part of old change received years ago. Back when the Susan B. Anthony dollar was in circulation, it wasn’t particularly popular and was often mistaken for a quarter due to its size.

“She had no clue,” said a café employee. “She just thought it was a regular dollar coin and used it without a second thought.”

Though the woman’s identity remains private, it’s reported that she was later informed of the coin’s enormous value. Remarkably, the barista who had kept the coin made the effort to find her and return it—an act of integrity that earned praise online and within the coin collecting community.

A Wake-Up Call for Coin Owners

This extraordinary story serves as a reminder that rare and valuable coins might be hiding in plain sight—in wallets, old coin jars, or inherited collections. Susan B. Anthony dollars from 1979, 1980, and 1981 may seem ordinary but can hold significant value, particularly if they have unique proof finishes or rare mint marks.

Collectors recommend examining coins carefully, especially older ones, and getting them professionally graded if they appear unusual.

Final Thoughts

In a world dominated by digital transactions, this incredible find highlights the ongoing value of physical currency. A nearly $1 million coin used casually to buy coffee reminds us that historic treasures may still be in our pockets. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or someone who’s never looked closely at your change, it might be time to take another look—because you never know what you might find.

FAQs