What began as a casual clean-up in a suburban garage has turned into a story shaking up the coin collecting world
What started as an ordinary clean-up project in a suburban garage has become a headline-making moment in the coin collecting community. An Illinois woman made national news after discovering that what she thought was a Chuck E. Cheese token was actually a rare 1979 Susan B. Anthony dollar coin — now estimated to be worth a jaw-dropping $790,000.
The discovery was made by 42-year-old Melanie Carter while she was organizing an old toy chest in her parents’ basement. Among the collection of dusty arcade tokens and leftover party trinkets, she spotted a shiny coin with the image of a woman. Believing it to be a game token from the 1980s, she added it to a box of novelty items. It wasn’t until a friend with a passion for coin collecting examined the coin that its true significance came to light.
A Rare Anthony Dollar With a Costly Error
Experts quickly identified the coin as a 1979 Susan B. Anthony dollar featuring a rare and highly sought-after minting flaw: the “Wide Rim” variation. Not only was the coin uncirculated and in pristine condition, but it also showcased an extremely rare doubling error on the reverse side, where the eagle is depicted.
According to numismatic specialist Charles Dunning from New York, this particular coin ranks among the finest examples ever found. “What makes this piece exceptionally valuable is both the rare minting error and the fact that it has remained untouched for over four decades,” Dunning said. “Its flawless condition is what elevates it from rare to extraordinary.”
Mistaken Identity: Arcade Token or Treasure?
The resemblance between Susan B. Anthony dollars and Chuck E. Cheese tokens has led to confusion before. Both are similar in size and appearance, leading many to overlook their true value. The Anthony dollar, minted in 1979–1981 and again in 1999, is often mistaken for quarters or tokens, especially by those unfamiliar with its background.
“I remember loving Chuck E. Cheese as a kid,” said Melanie. “When I came across the coin, I honestly thought it was from a birthday party. I didn’t realize I was holding a collector’s item that’s now worth nearly $800,000!”
Auction Bidders Already Circling
The coin’s unexpected discovery has caught the attention of major players in the numismatic world. Representatives from leading auction houses say that early interest from collectors is strong. The coin could command a final sale price of over $790,000, depending on how it’s graded and the level of competition among bidders.
“This kind of discovery is extremely rare,” said a spokesperson for Heritage Auctions. “It’s not every day that a coin of this caliber emerges from a family’s forgotten memorabilia. It’s the kind of story that excites both experts and the general public.”
Why Susan B. Anthony Coins Are Making Headlines
In recent times, Susan B. Anthony dollars have seen a resurgence in interest among collectors. Initially met with lukewarm reception due to their similarity to quarters, these coins are now recognized for their historical relevance and the unique minting errors that make some of them particularly valuable.
Melanie’s chance finding is a strong reminder that everyday objects can sometimes hold incredible worth. In this instance, what seemed like a forgotten childhood token turned out to be a six-figure piece of American history.
Final Word
This surprising event has sparked renewed interest in coin collecting across the nation. Experts urge anyone with jars of old coins or childhood collections to give them a second look. You never know — a forgotten coin at the bottom of a drawer could be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.
FAQs
Q1: Why is the 1979 Susan B. Anthony dollar so valuable?
A: Certain 1979 Susan B. Anthony dollars are rare because of specific minting errors like the “Wide Rim” and doubling on the reverse. If these coins are also in perfect, uncirculated condition, their value can soar.
Q2: How can I tell if I have a valuable coin?
A: Look for unique features like minting errors, unusual rim spacing, or doubling on images or text. Having the coin evaluated by a certified numismatist or coin grading service can help determine its value.
Q3: Where can I sell a rare coin like this?
A: You can sell rare coins through reputable auction houses such as Heritage Auctions or Stack’s Bowers, or consult with a licensed coin dealer. Online marketplaces also offer selling platforms but come with more risk.
Q4: Are all Susan B. Anthony coins worth money?
A: Most Susan B. Anthony dollars hold only face value unless they feature minting errors, are part of a rare variety, or are in exceptional condition. Collectors prize unique examples, not every coin minted.
